I have been living in a refugees camp in Munich, Bavaria (for the past 6 years ) as my residency is according to Article 60a (Duldung), the social welfare office has been deducting €51.24 from my essential social benefits (I'm surviving only on €370 monthly) for the past three years when I asked about the reason they claimed it's according to "EVS 2018 §§5-6 RBEG i.V.m § 27a Abs. 4 SGB XII" break down as follows :
Division (4) Housing, Energy, Maintenance deduction: €36.87
Division (5) household effects, except additional amount deduction: €14.37
Total deduction: €51.24
Now the problem is, The vast majority of camp residents are NOT paying anything (people on jobcentre or working), only three or four residents are receiving this deduction directly from the social office each month (including myself) while the rest are not paying anything (more than 100 resident ), No maintenance was made in the past three years and we don't have cleaning service (we clean ourselves ), We DO NOT receive any other services ( we don't even have a fully functional kitchen), so I cannot imagine any reason for this deduction?
furthermore, I was told that these expenses were overturned by the administrative court and nobody is still paying in other camps.
My question is: is this deduction legal? is it still valid? and what should I do given the above mentioned facts?