Here you can ask, answer and find questions surrounding the topic: arriving in Germany
Last week I have been granted resident permit according to 19d (1) Nr. 1c valid for 3 years. I'm living with my wife and 2 children. Our marriage is registered in Germany. My daughter is going to kita and my son is only 1 years old now. My wife is a housewife. We have a separate flat (enough rspace) and I have a permanent work contract. My question is when I have been granted a resident permit why my family has not been granted a permit? Why are they still on Duldung? (Extended every 3 months). I talked to my lawyer she said i can apply simply according to Ehegatten und kindernachzug and ask further help from ausländerbehorde. Then I talked to ausländerbehorde. I have to apply according to 25 (5), they replied. But paragraph 25 (5) is about permit according to humanitarian base. When I apply according to this my family will not be able to fly to mother country. Thats why I don't want to apply according to 25. Can please someone help me and guide me? According to which para should I apply? Because as far as I know. The status of the family will be the same as the status of the family head. When I have been granted a permit then why not my family is automatic eligible?
Please reply me here because I have already tried mBeon app but nobody interested there to reply. Thanks in advance.

asked Oct 30, 2021 in Legal advice by Refusegee

Please log in or register to answer this question.

1 Answer

0 votes

Dear @Refusegee,

Welcome back to the Wefugees Community and thank you for reaching out to us again.

I am also not experienced with the residence permit according to 19d of the German Residence Act. However, I remember that we discussed the family situation in the context of this residence permit once here before. 

Then, I will also link two of my colleagues working with mbeon. Dear @mbeon-ruth or @mbeon-fardeen, can @Refusegee reach out to you or can you give any recommendation?

All the best,


answered Nov 4, 2021 by Meike
Thanks Meike for your reply. N let's see when will I get contacted from the linked persons. As I have to apply as soon as possible.

I'm still waiting for my question to be answered here. It's over 10 days now n nobody is interested to help. @meike replied and pinned 2 of his expert to help me further but over 10 days now and I'm still waiting. Seems like this group is completely useless and just to make fun of people. I would suggest people to not waste time here to get free advice. Because nothing is free. Just Google and hire a lawyer for your case instead of wasting your time here. It better to pay some amount to a lawyer because you don't have to go through a pain to waiting here to get free advice. Sorry but its true.

4,045 questions
4,816 answers
136,527 users